A report from the Scottish Affairs Committee argues that new crossings could deliver considerable social and economic benefits in locations where such projects are practical and financially viable. The committee is urging the Government to engage more actively with proposals for bridges and tunnels, including exploring how it could provide support for their development.
The recommendations follow concerns about the condition and reliability of existing ferry services, which many island residents depend on for essential journeys. MPs believe alternative infrastructure could help improve connectivity and provide greater certainty for communities affected by ageing and increasingly unreliable vessels.
However, the report makes clear that bridges and tunnels should complement existing ferry networks rather than replace them. Such developments would only be appropriate for certain shorter crossings, meaning ferries would continue to play an essential role in connecting many of Scotland's islands. The committee also emphasises that local communities must have the final say on whether individual projects should progress, with decisions driven by the needs and priorities of island residents.
Patricia Ferguson MP, chair of the Scottish Affairs Committee, said: “Scotland's island communities deserve better than their unreliable ferry services, which place intolerable limitations on islanders going about their daily life - from accessing healthcare and education, to running businesses. Our report finds that, where viable, fixed links like bridges and tunnels could bring transformative benefits to these communities.
Of course, any decision to pursue these projects rests first and foremost with islanders themselves. It's also crucial to recognise that bridges and tunnels would complement, not replace, ferry services. For many, ferries will remain essential – improving their reliability must remain an urgent priority.”